A symphony of flavors

Explore my delectable menu of fresh-baked, gourmet chalk-lit chip cookies, crafted with love in Budd Lake, New Jersey. Each cookie is made to order, ensuring a taste experience that's beyond the ordinary. Get ready to treat yourself to a world of unique flavors and delightful combinations!

Chalk-lit chip cookie flavors

Indulge in my irresistible selection of gourmet chalk-lit chip cookies inspired by Baked by the Lake. Each cookie is baked fresh to order using only the finest ingredients. From classic favorites to unique creations, there's a flavor to satisfy every craving.

Stuffed salted caramel

A sweet and savory delight, featuring my signature chalk-lit chip cookie with a gooey caramel center.

Reese stuffed peanut butter

Peanut butter lovers rejoice! A chalk-lit chip cookie stuffed with a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup for the ultimate indulgence.

Cookie monster

A fun and playful chalk-lit chip cookie packed with colorful chocolate chips and chunks of your favorite blue monster's namesake cookies.

Chocolate chip oreo

A classic combination! My chalk-lit chip cookie with chunks of Oreo cookies baked right in.

Oatmeal m&m

A chewy and colorful twist on a classic! My oatmeal cookie loaded with M&M's.

Almond joy

Inspired by the candy bar, this chalk-lit chip cookie features almonds, coconut, and chocolate chunks.

Customization & ordering

Order your favorite chalk-lit chip cookies today! I offer a dozen for $35, half dozen for $20, and you can mix and match your favorite flavors to create the perfect assortment. Contact me via email at chalklitchipcookie@gmail.com to place your order.

Made to order

Kay's cookies are baked fresh to order, ensuring you receive the highest quality and best-tasting treats. I take pride in our attention to detail and commitment to using only the finest ingredients.

Unique ingredients

What sets Kay's cookies apart? I use special touches like stuffing them with creamy caramel or a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup for an explosion of flavor in every bite. Taste the difference that quality ingredients and creative baking make!